Clear, 83° Complete Forecast
Rate this (Avg 3.0)
Lawyers trying to clean out Colfax
Point
Bruce Kranz, Colfax City Manager

On May 12, the Colfax City Council unanimously declared the city faced unreasonable hardship, even bankruptcy, if it were not allowed to make installment payments on massive monetary judgments impending against the city.

The citizens and taxpayers of Colfax deserve to know the truth about lawsuits against the city.

Lawyers for Clean Water are surely all for cleaning up Colfax … and then some.

As is well-known to the poor citizens of the city, Colfax has been struggling for some years to clean up an old, tired, leaking, sewage system.

The city has borrowed money, increased fees and received grants to build a new state-of-the-art sewage treatment plant and now to begin to replace miles of old pipes, both public and private.

Under existing law the new plant must produce water cleaner — in the case of copper 100 times cleaner — than drinking water.

That’s the law and the Colfax plant complies, but its pipes do not. There is a long way, many miles of pipe, and many million dollars to go, but the city is trying to do the best it can to comply with the law and protect the public’s health.

In the midst of this mess and fiscal nightmare, Lawyers for Clean Water, have flown into town, allegedly to assist damaged neighbors suing the city.

In fact, San Francisco-based lawyers paid $550 an hour, eating a celebratory $125 lunch at Il Fornaio and giving 40 percent tips are acting like vultures feasting upon Colfax like it was roadkill.

Perhaps they think they are dealing with country mountain hicks, who won’t catch what they are doing.

Lawyers for Clean Water, doing business as Environmental Law Foundation, might be more accurately called Lawyers to Clean Out Colfax. They seem bent on picking the pockets of penniless Colfax.

Instead of honoring a contract — a settlement — they signed to limit attorney fees, they are demanding fees and costs more than triple the settlement cap they previously agreed to.

They are demanding exorbitant attorney fees, as much as $550 an hour and reimbursements for costs, such as $125 lunches.

They are demanding preemptive, immediate payment for services not yet completed in the ongoing case and without a hearing to determine the reasonableness of their fees and costs. They are double billing, back billing, the city’s taxpayers for services for which they have already been paid.

They want to pay an apprentice lawyer with 18 months experience in environmental law $350 an hour.

They are claiming lawyer time well over twice that of the city’s attorney doing the same work, on the same motions on the same case.

They want to be paid unsubstantiated, undocumented and unexplained cost for computers, travel, research economist, meals etc.

We are appealing to the judge to hold payments until the end; cap fees to the limit agreed to in the settlement; accept reasonable fees for lawyers in the Sacramento region rather than San Francisco; and to allow the city to pay annual installments.

Lawyers ought to be paid reasonable fees and no more.

Not registered? Click here
E-mail this
Print this
Comments
9 comments on this item

Wow Bruce - I am almost ready to pack up the pick-up truck and head to Colfax with food and clothing! - But seriously I do not feel Colfax should be brought to it's knees by a couple lawyers and selfish individuals - good luck

Question - has anyone in Placer County gotten sick or died form the normal discharge from any of our wastewater plants? How does our water compare to other industrialized country's? - I am just curious - it seems the hoops we are being forced to jump through seem a little high for this simpleton - but I was wrong once before! Don't get me wrong, I want clean water - but....

Bring back septic tanks.

Yes septic tanks...

I agree with the editorial just below Kranz' that he's spending more time lawyer & Edwards bashing than handling the problem. Kranz must really be feeling the financial pinch if he thinks $125 is exhorbitant for a lunch..not that expensive for 3 or more...he conveniently leaves out how many people were eating.

If I was a Colfax resident, I wouldn't be too happy with his "penniless" portrayal.

He just goes out of his way to overstate the case.

loungelizard,

It doesn't matter to me if there were 15 lawyers eating lunch at McDonald's. Colfax is a tiny little town with no money. If there was any money in Colfax, it would be spent on the sewage system. Colfax residents have pitched numerous huge fits over rate increases because they can't afford to pay more. Bruce is right, these lawyers and the get-rich-quick folks who hire them are vultures.

Where do you live, loungelizard? Sounds like the economy there is smokin' hot. Maybe I should move.

When dealing with lawyers, should anyone be surprised? And why should Colfax be forced to buy lawyers any lunch at any price? At $550 an hour they could buy their own lunch! What a pathetic profession.

I don't understand Kranz's motivation for this long rant, accurate or not. He makes 17 points and then says, in effect, "we're appealing all these points with the judge". Well, fine. Good luck...I guess.

But what was the point of the editorial? To vent against lawyers? To justify the appeal? To make excuses? To motivate people to...what? lobby the judge? If it was to educate, he fails. No politician persuades me when he resorts to describing the opposition as "vultures".

Seems to me what Kranz really wants is to keep himself in the political spotlight.

Kranz and the city are pathetic.

I don't know why Bruce Kranz would want to keep himself in the political spotlight. He lost his Board of Supervisor's seat to a Democrat in the reddest county in California because of his deep admiration for John Doolittle. Now he is a complete failure as a City Manager. I wish he would move out of the county.

You must be logged in to post a comment. click here to log in.
Change Location:
Post your stories, blogs, photos, videos and events

Contents of this site are all Copyright © 2010, Gold Country Media. All rights reserved. Powered By: Creative Circle Advertising Solutions, Inc.

Privacy Policy  Terms of Service